Return to Table of Contents

Go to Course Listings

Go to bottom of document
Go to middle of document

Go to: Program Requirements
Go to: Summary of Requirements
Go to: Faculty

Ideas and Methods

Program Chairman: David Smigelskis, C 326, 702-7125

Secretary: Delores A. Jackson, C 330, 702-7148

Program of Study

The program in Ideas and Methods (I&M) is designed for College students who want to combine serious investigation of a subject matter with organized reflection on how problems are formulated and subject matters defined and investigated.

Students come into the program with a question or an interest broad enough to be developed into a set of problems in a field of knowledge, but not so broad that it is a cosmic puzzle or a passion for something as vague as "literature" or "science." This interest may be in any of the conventional fields of knowledge or cut across them. Usually, however, it is not one that could be easily pursued in other undergraduate programs as they are presently organized.

Program Requirements

The I&M program proceeds on the hypothesis that no subject matter is ever investigated without working assumptions about what subject matters there may be and how a problem is formulated. Reflection on these questions therefore requires thinking about what such assumptions might be and how they work. It develops easily into such questions as what procedures are available for tackling problems and organizing materials into subject matters. The program is designed to encourage and demand reflection on these dimensions of thinking as conditions affecting not only the development of the student's special interest but of all interests.

Go to top of document
Go to bottom of document

The core of the I&M program therefore consists of two sorts of courses and tutorial work. Some courses are designed to pursue directly the student's special interest. Most of these would normally not be I&M courses; rather, they are selected from offerings elsewhere in the College. Another group of courses is designed to stimulate the kind of reflective examination of assumptions described above. These are mostly, but not exclusively, I&M courses. Some I&M courses are intended to examine the possibilities and the difficulties of formulating and practicing a "method" or a "discipline." Others are designed to exemplify the process of carrying on an inquiry in the context of examined assumptions about the asking of questions and the ways in which answers to them can be developed. The junior and senior papers function as points at which both sides of this core are brought to a manageable focus by each student. In them, students should practice for themselves, with faculty guidance, the kind of disciplined and self-conscious inquiry the program aims to encourage.

Summary of Requirements

6 I&M core courses as described under Program Requirements. These courses vary with the student and yearly offerings.

5 NCD 299 (Independent Study)

11 (total)

It is expected that the student also takes courses specifically relevant to the junior and senior projects as background for the independent study work.

Go to top of document
Go to bottom of document

Grading, Transcripts, and Recommendations. The independent study and major papers required by the New Collegiate Division are best evaluated in faculty statements on the nature and quality of the work. In support of the independent study grades of Pass, Incomplete, and No Credit, faculty supervisors are asked to submit such statements to student files maintained in the NCD office. Responses to the major papers and copies of the papers themselves are also available in this collection of statements, which is used to support graduate applications and to evaluate NCD candidates for Phi Beta Kappa, College honors, and other awards. Students should request statements of reference from faculty with whom they have worked.

At the student's request, the registrar includes the following statement with each transcript:

The New Collegiate Division works with a small, selected group of students. There is less emphasis on letter grades than in other Collegiate Divisions and greater emphasis on independent work (NCD 299), including substantial papers submitted at the end of the junior and senior years. Students do some substantial portion of their work in close association with a tutor or tutors, and this work is graded Pass/No Pass only. Grades are supplemented with qualitative statements available from the Master, New Collegiate Division, The University of Chicago, 5811 South Ellis Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60637.

Go to top of document
Go to bottom of document

Honors. Honors are awarded in all the New Collegiate Division concentrations. In I&M, the essential requirement for honors is an exceptionally distinguished senior paper. Papers considered worthy of honors by the initial readers are referred to a third reader whose identity is unknown to the student. In addition, honors depend on the student's grades, especially in the concentration; 3.25 is roughly the floor, but because a good deal of NCD work tends to be ungraded, the grade point standard cannot be stated precisely. Faculty evaluations of ungraded work are taken into account along with grades.

Faculty

PHILIP W. JACKSON, David Lee Shillinglaw Distinguished Service Professor, Departments of Education and Psychology (Human Development), Committee on the Analysis of Ideas & the Study of Methods, and the College

DONALD N. LEVINE, Peter B. Ritzma Professor, Department of Sociology and the College

WENDY RAUDENBUSH OLMSTED, Associate Professor, Division of the Humanities and the College

MICHAEL SILVERSTEIN, Samuel N. Harper Professor, Departments of Anthropology, Linguistics, and Psychology (Cognition & Communication) and Committee on Analysis of Ideas & Study of Methods

DAVID SMIGELSKIS, Associate Professor, Division of the Humanities and the College; Chairman, Committee on Analysis of Ideas & Study of Methods

DAVID TRACY, Andrew Thomas Greeley and Grace McNichols Greeley Distinguished Service Professor, the Divinity School and Committees on Analysis of Ideas & Study of Methods and Social Thought

Go to top of document